Fishing Hemingway’s Last Good Country

// Written by Dave Westburg
// Photography by Dave Westburg, Steven Westburg and Greg Nelson

Many of Ernest Hemingway’s Nick Adams short stories are set in upper Michigan or refer to it. Hemingway spent his boyhood summers at Walloon Lake.

He lived in Horton Bay as a struggling young writer and was married in the town’s Methodist Church. He learned to fish in Horton Creek and took camping trips nearby to the Sturgeon and the Black Rivers.  

 

— “This is the way forests were in the olden days. This is about the last good country there is left.”  Ernest Hemingway, The Last Good Country —

 

In early September, my son, a friend and I travelled to Horton Bay, Michigan to see the ground and fish the rivers. It was fall and the leaves were just starting to turn red. Hunters patrolled the backroads with hound dogs in their pickups searching for bear.

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryHorton Bay General Store

 

We stayed upstairs at the Horton Bay General Store. It’s thought to be the model for the general store in Hemingway’s short story The Last Good Country. It looks the same today as it did in Hemingway’s time: a high false storefront outside and a sprawling interior with a huge bar over which you can buy everything from ice cream to whiskey to pastries to goat cheese to a sack of nails.

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryInterior of Horton Bay General Store

 

We spent a frustrating afternoon fishing Horton Creek. Hemingway learned to fish in Horton Creek. There are several pictures of Hemingway with Horton Creek brook trout. His character Nick Adams muses about fishing the creek after a rain in one of the Nick Adams stories. We struck out. The creek’s wadeable water below town is private property and off limits to fishing.  In the Nick Adams Preserve above town, the creek’s marl bottom is unwadeable, the water is gin-clear and the fish are skittish. Brush along the steam and low hanging branches make casting very difficult. I had fish turn away from a size 16 Adams and a size 18 Black Ant and spooked several others while trying to get into position to cast.

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryCasting for the impossible trout in the Nick Adams Preserve

 

The next day we drove an hour east of Horton Bay to the Black River. The Black was a Hemingway favorite. Its amber colored water flows through the Pigeon State forest. It’s the largest contiguous block or wild country on the Lower Peninsula. The Black River bends and deadfalls shelter wild brook trout. The public access points on the Black have evocative names like Green’s Landing, McKinnon Bend, Tin Shanty Bridge, Chandler Dam Road, The Stairs, Hardwood Creek and Crockett Rapids. The upper black is brushy and hard to wade with a deep mud and sand bottom. The banks are more open and the river bottom is more rocky the farther downstream you go. We found brook trout below Tin Shanty Bridge on the upper Black (a favorite Hemingway stretch) but it was very brushy.  

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryBrushy water on the Black River below Tin Shanty Bridge

 

We did better in an open stretch of the Black along Chandler Dam Road (another Hemingway camping spot) catching brook trout of 6-12 inches fishing size 12 Letort Hoppers and size 14 yellow humpies.

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryFishing a Letort Hopper on The Black River off Chandler Road

 

We completed our trip with a hike to the Hardwood Creek stretch of the Black. The Hardwood Creek water requires a walk on a deserted two-lane track through forest and a meadow towards the ravine which holds the river. 

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryWoods and Meadow near Black River

 

The woods near the river made me think of the conversation Nick Adams and his sister had while hiking deep into the forest to avoid the game wardens who want to arrest Nick for poaching trout.

 

“Did you ever come here with anyone else?”

“No. Only by myself.”

“And you weren’t afraid.”

“No. But I always feel strange. Like the way I ought to feel in church.”

 

Ernest Hemingway, The Last Good Country

 

Hemingway used a Bamboo Hardy Fairy fly rod and a Hardy St George Reel but he didn’t fish dry flies. “Papa was a pretty straightforward wet-fly fisherman,” his son Jack says in Misadventures of a Fly Fisherman. “Ninety percent of the time, Papa was an across and downstream caster whose team of flies swam or skittered across the current…”  Hemingway liked to fish the McGinty wet fly, a colorful bee imitation listed in Mary Orvis Marbury’s Favorite Flies and Their Histories.

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryMcGinty Wet Flies

 

Hook: #8-14 Heavy wire wet fly hook (or else the fly will skate).

 

Tail: Red hen hackle.

 

Body: Small yellow and black chenille wound together.

 

Hackle: Brown or furnace hackle.

 

Wing: White tipped mallard blues.

 

Thread: Black

 

We found some riffles in the Hardwood Creek stretch of the Black suitable for a downstream wet fly swum Hemingway fashion across the current. Hemingway’s description of a book trout caught by Nick Adams in The Last Good Country says it all: “He was strong and heavy in Nick’s hands and he had a pleasant smell and Nick saw how dark his back was and how brilliant his spots were colored and how bright the edges of his fins were. They were white on the edge with a black line behind…”

 

Fishing Hemingway's Last Good CountryRiffles in the Hardwood Creek

 

Time passed quickly. This won’t be our last trip to the last good country.